What are good book club discussion questions for Adversary To The Villain?

Spoiler-free questions to get the conversation going: Settle in with your warm drink: which character in Evie's orbit would you most want on your side during a chaotic day, and why?; What was the first moment in this book that made you smile or laugh out loud, the kind you wanted to read aloud to someone?; Evie has a knack for finding warmth and belonging in the most unlikely (and villainous) places. Where in your own life have you found comfort somewhere you did not expect?; This series treats a den of villainy almost like a cozy workplace family. Which scene here felt the most like coming home, and what made it feel that way to you?; The banter between Evie and the Villain is equal parts prickly and tender. Which exchange melted you a little, and did it remind you of any relationship in your own life?.

What food and drinks should I serve at a Adversary To The Villain book club?

Food: Villain's Lair Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup, Evie's Apple Hand Pies, and Frog-Friendly Herbed Popcorn. Drinks: Spiced Apple Cider (warm), Honey Chamomile Tea, and Mulled Wine 'Potion'.

Cozy night

Adversary To The VillainBook club questions, food & host guide

Hannah Nicole Maehrer

A cozy book club night for Adversary To The Villain by Hannah Nicole Maehrer. Includes 8 spoiler-free discussion questions, food and drink pairings, a playlist, and a host guide, ready to print and share.

A warm, laughter-loving club that adores swoony banter and character-first comfort reads

Print / Save PDF Build another Get it on Bookshop.org Get it on Amazon

Buy links are affiliate links; we may earn a small commission, at no cost to you.

The fourth cozy-fantasy romp in the Assistant and the Villain series, where Evie Sage tangles deeper with evil, mischief, and a certain infuriatingly charming Villain. It is a low-stakes-feeling, banter-rich comfort read that practically begs to be talked about over tea.

Why it works for clubs

Lovable, bickering characters give everyone a favorite to gush about
Cozy villainy and workplace-of-doom humor make for easy, laughter-filled chat
A fandom-favorite series means fans arrive already emotionally invested
Slow-burn romance and found-family warmth invite personal, heartfelt sharing

Themes & mood

cozy fantasy enemies-to-something found family banter whimsical

Browse all themes →

Reading level

Easy

Warm-up questions

1 Settle in with your warm drink: which character in Evie's orbit would you most want on your side during a chaotic day, and why?
2 What was the first moment in this book that made you smile or laugh out loud, the kind you wanted to read aloud to someone?

Digging in

1 Evie has a knack for finding warmth and belonging in the most unlikely (and villainous) places. Where in your own life have you found comfort somewhere you did not expect?
2 This series treats a den of villainy almost like a cozy workplace family. Which scene here felt the most like coming home, and what made it feel that way to you?
3 The banter between Evie and the Villain is equal parts prickly and tender. Which exchange melted you a little, and did it remind you of any relationship in your own life?
4 If you could curl up inside one gentle, low-stakes moment from this book, which would you choose to linger in a while longer?

Going deep

1 By the end, Evie is more ensnared than ever in a world that blurs good and wicked. Setting spoilers aside, how did watching her navigate that pull make you feel, and did it comfort or unsettle you?
2 Four books in, this feels like visiting old friends. Without giving anything away, what did this installment give your heart that you did not know you needed from the series?

On the table

Villain's Lair Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup

The ultimate no-fuss comfort duo for a story about finding warmth inside a den of scheming; easy to make in a big batch.

Evie's Apple Hand Pies

Sweet, portable, a little indulgent, and fitting for a whimsical fantasy world; store-bought crust keeps the effort moderate.

Frog-Friendly Herbed Popcorn

A playful nod to the series' beloved animal companions and quirky magic; toss with butter and herbs and set out in bowls to graze.

To sip

Spiced Apple Cider (warm) No alcohol

A cozy, non-alcoholic hug in a mug that suits the fantasy-village mood; simmer with cinnamon sticks and orange.

Honey Chamomile Tea No alcohol

Gentle and soothing for warm, unhurried conversation, perfect for the low-pressure vibe.

Mulled Wine 'Potion'

A gently spiced, wickedly warm brew for an evening spent among villains; keep it on low heat all night.

Soft, playful, and a little swoony: gentle acoustic warmth with a mischievous wink

Tap a track to play it. Full songs play when you're signed into Spotify.

You're invited

Cozy Night with the Villain (and Us)

Bring your softest sweater and biggest appetite for banter. We are curling up with 'Adversary To The Villain', warm drinks, and comfort food for a gentle, giggly evening together.

Trivia

1

What is the name of the series this book belongs to?

Answer: The Assistant and the Villain series.
2

Which number book in the series is 'Adversary To The Villain'?

Answer: The fourth book.
3

Who is the author?

Answer: Hannah Nicole Maehrer.
4

What is the name of the series' central heroine?

Answer: Evie Sage.
5

On which social media platform did this story first find a huge audience before publication?

Answer: TikTok (where Maehrer serialized 'The Villain's Assistant').
6

What broad genre blend is this series best known for?

Answer: Cozy, comedic romantic fantasy.
7

The heroine works as an assistant to whom?

Answer: The Villain.
8

True or false: this book is a standalone with no prior installments?

Answer: False; it is the fourth entry in an ongoing series.