Discipline
Larissa Pham's essay collection braids art, desire, grief, and the long work of healing into prose that feels like a letter from a close friend. It is short enough to finish in a weekend and generous enough to keep a room talking all night.
We are reading Larissa Pham's Discipline, a slim book about art, wanting, and healing slowly. Bring your dog-eared pages, wear something soft, there will be congee and cake and a very warm teapot.
Best for: A small, trusting club that likes memoir and personal essays and does not mind the conversation getting a little soft-hearted.
Discussion
Warm-up
- 1.Where did you do most of your reading for this one, and did the book ask for a particular kind of quiet?
- 2.Pham writes so closely about looking at art. Is there one painting, song, or photograph you keep returning to the way she returns to hers?
Digging in
- 1.The title promises discipline, but the book keeps finding tenderness inside it. Did that reframing comfort you at all, or did it sting a little?
- 2.This is a book about wanting things badly. What did it stir up in you about your own appetites, and were you glad to feel it?
- 3.Pham treats attention as a form of love. Did reading her pay closer attention change how you looked at anything in your own week?
- 4.The essays move between art, friendship, and solitude. Which of those three felt most like company to you while you read?
Going deep
- 1.Pham is writing about healing while it is still unfinished. Did sitting with something unresolved feel generous to you, or did part of you want her to tie it off?
- 2.By the final pages, what had the book softened in you that you did not expect to be softened? Share only as much as you want to.
On the table & to sip
To eat
To sip
Run of show
Host tips
- Say out loud at the start that nobody has to share anything personal. The book invites confession, and permission to pass is what makes honest talk possible.
- Cook everything the day before. Congee and sheet cake both improve overnight and you want your hands free to host, not stir.
- Keep a stack of sticky notes by the door so people can flag passages on arrival. It gives shy readers an easy way in.
Playlist
Hushed and reverb-soft, the sound of a lamp-lit room where someone is telling you the truth.
- 01 Motion Sickness - Phoebe Bridgers
- 02 Pink Rabbits - The National
- 03 River - Joni Mitchell
- 04 Cellophane - FKA twigs
- 05 Night Shift - Lucy Dacus
- 06 Blood Bank - Bon Iver
- 07 Spring and Summer - Mitski
- 08 An Ending (Ascent) - Brian Eno
Trivia
- 1.What is the full title of the book under discussion? (Pop Song: Adventures in Art and Intimacy. The night's theme centers on the Discipline essay within it.)
- 2.What literary form is the book written in? (The personal or lyric essay, collected as a book-length work of nonfiction.)
- 3.In what year was the collection published? (2021.)
- 4.Which American contemporary artist, known for text-based light and sculptural works, appears among the artists Pham writes about? (Louise Bourgeois is among the artists she engages with in the collection.)
- 5.Pham has also published a work of short fiction. What is its title? (Fantasian, a novella.)
- 6.What two subjects does the book's subtitle pair together? (Art and intimacy.)
- 7.Besides books, where has Pham's criticism and essay work appeared? (Publications including The Nation, The Paris Review Daily, and Guernica, among other outlets.)
- 8.Which broad theme runs alongside art-looking throughout the collection: adventure travel, legal history, or desire and healing? (Desire and healing.)
Bookmarks
Print, cut, and tuck one at every seat, a small keepsake from the night.
“Look long enough and the looking becomes a kind of love.”
“Some wanting is just the heart keeping itself warm.”
“Healing is slow on purpose. Sit down. Stay awhile.”
Rate the book
We hope the company was good and the conversation even better. Until the next chapter.