What are good book club discussion questions for F*Ck Failure?

Spoiler-free questions to get the conversation going: Before we get into it: what is one small thing you tried this year that did not go the way you hoped, and can you tell it as a funny story now?; Was there a page where you felt the author was talking directly to you, and what were you doing when that happened (couch, commute, 2am)?; The book treats failure as something to say out loud rather than hide. Whose voice in your own life gave you permission to admit a flop, and how did it feel to finally say it?; Benny Blanco writes from inside a creative career where rejection is routine. Did reading that make your own setbacks feel lighter, or did it make you a little envious of how casually he shrugs?; Which piece of encouragement here did you actually believe, and which one made you think 'easy for you to say'? No wrong answers, we are all a little skeptical.

What food and drinks should I serve at a F*Ck Failure book club?

Food: Slow-cooker mac and cheese with a crunchy top, Burnt-edge brownies, cut unevenly on purpose, and Tomato soup in mugs with grilled cheese soldiers. Drinks: Hot cocoa bar with marshmallows, cinnamon, and a tin of whipped cream, Spiked hot apple cider with a cinnamon stick, and Irish coffee, or 'the second take'.

Cozy night

F*Ck FailureBook club questions, food & host guide

Benny Blanco

#6 New York Times Bestseller 1 week on the list

A cozy book club night for F*Ck Failure by Benny Blanco. Includes 8 spoiler-free discussion questions, food and drink pairings, a playlist, and a host guide, ready to print and share.

A club that likes a quick, uplifting read and would rather swap real stories than dissect a text

Print / Save PDF Build another Get it on Bookshop.org Get it on Amazon

Buy links are affiliate links; we may earn a small commission, at no cost to you.

A candid, encouraging take on failure from a music producer who built a career out of false starts and second tries, offered less as a lecture than as a friend talking you down off the ledge. It is short, warm, and absolutely made for a room of people who have all quietly flopped at something.

Why it works for clubs

Everyone arrives with their own failure story, so nobody shows up with nothing to say
The tone is conversational and unpolished, which invites honest talk instead of performance
Creative-life themes (rejection, persistence, self-doubt) land for artists and non-artists alike
Short and breezy, so even the member who fell behind can still join in

Themes & mood

Pep talk Creative life Second chances Messy and honest Self-compassion

Browse all themes →

Reading level

Easy

Warm-up questions

1 Before we get into it: what is one small thing you tried this year that did not go the way you hoped, and can you tell it as a funny story now?
2 Was there a page where you felt the author was talking directly to you, and what were you doing when that happened (couch, commute, 2am)?

Digging in

1 The book treats failure as something to say out loud rather than hide. Whose voice in your own life gave you permission to admit a flop, and how did it feel to finally say it?
2 Benny Blanco writes from inside a creative career where rejection is routine. Did reading that make your own setbacks feel lighter, or did it make you a little envious of how casually he shrugs?
3 Which piece of encouragement here did you actually believe, and which one made you think 'easy for you to say'? No wrong answers, we are all a little skeptical.
4 The title is loud, but a lot of the feeling underneath is tender. Where did the book feel most gentle with you, and did you need that this week?

Going deep

1 If you could hand this book to a younger version of yourself at one specific low point, which point would you choose, and what do you think she or he would have done differently with that pep talk in hand?
2 By the time you closed it, had anything actually shifted in how you talk to yourself about a thing you gave up on? Be honest if the answer is 'not yet, but maybe'.

On the table

Slow-cooker mac and cheese with a crunchy top

The ultimate 'it is fine, come sit down' food, and a nod to a book about making peace with the messy middle. Make it ahead, keep it warm, let people go back for seconds.

Burnt-edge brownies, cut unevenly on purpose

The imperfect corner pieces are the best part, which is basically the whole thesis. Serve them piled on a plate, no styling.

Tomato soup in mugs with grilled cheese soldiers

Handheld, comforting, and easy to eat while someone else is telling a long story about the job they did not get.

To sip

Hot cocoa bar with marshmallows, cinnamon, and a tin of whipped cream No alcohol

Nurturing, low effort, and it gives everyone something to fuss over during the quiet parts of the conversation.

Spiked hot apple cider with a cinnamon stick

Warm, a little indulgent, and loosens people up just enough to admit the embarrassing stuff.

Irish coffee, or 'the second take'

A gentle late-evening pick-me-up for a book about trying again after the first attempt flopped.

Soft, hopeful pop and singer-songwriter warmth, kept low enough to talk over, the sound of a kitchen at 9pm with the good lamp on.

Tap a track to play it. Full songs play when you're signed into Spotify.