What are good book club discussion questions for Girl's Girl?

Spoiler-free questions to get the conversation going: Before we talk about the book at all: who was the first girl who felt like your person, and what did she teach you about being a friend?; When you saw the title "Girl's Girl" on the cover, what did you expect the book to be, and did it meet you there or somewhere softer?; Feldman is so good at the small kindnesses between women (the shared snack, the covered-for lie, the ride home). Which small kindness in this book made you feel most looked after, and why?; The book sits with jealousy without punishing anyone for it. How did it feel to read envy written that gently, and did it make you kinder about your own?; Which passage would you have read out loud to a friend in another room, and what about it made you want to hand it over?.

What food and drinks should I serve at a Girl's Girl book club?

Food: Sleepover grilled cheese, cut in triangles, A big pot of tomato soup with cream swirled in, and Slice-and-bake chocolate chip cookies, served warm. Drinks: Honey chamomile tea with lemon, Spiced hot cocoa with a splash of bourbon (optional pour), and A soft, chillable red (Beaujolais or Lambrusco).

Cozy night

Girl's GirlBook club questions, food & host guide

Sonia Feldman

Picked by

Belletrist

A cozy book club night for Girl's Girl by Sonia Feldman. Includes 8 spoiler-free discussion questions, food and drink pairings, a playlist, and a host guide, ready to print and share.

A close-knit club that likes talking about their own lives as much as the book, over second helpings

Print / Save PDF Build another Get it on Bookshop.org Get it on Amazon

Buy links are affiliate links; we may earn a small commission, at no cost to you.

Sonia Feldman's "Girl's Girl" is a sharp, tender look at the loyalties, envies, and small betrayals that live inside women's friendships. It reads fast and warm, and it leaves everyone with something they want to say out loud.

Why it works for clubs

Friendship, loyalty, and jealousy are things every reader has lived, so nobody arrives with nothing to say
The title itself is an argument, and clubs tend to split on what being a "girl's girl" actually requires
Feldman writes with a poet's compression, so single images and turns of phrase are worth lingering over
Short enough to finish comfortably, layered enough to reward a second pass

Themes & mood

Female friendship Tender and sharp Loyalty Contemporary Quietly funny

Browse all themes →

Reading level

Moderate

Warm-up questions

1 Before we talk about the book at all: who was the first girl who felt like your person, and what did she teach you about being a friend?
2 When you saw the title "Girl's Girl" on the cover, what did you expect the book to be, and did it meet you there or somewhere softer?

Digging in

1 Feldman is so good at the small kindnesses between women (the shared snack, the covered-for lie, the ride home). Which small kindness in this book made you feel most looked after, and why?
2 The book sits with jealousy without punishing anyone for it. How did it feel to read envy written that gently, and did it make you kinder about your own?
3 Which passage would you have read out loud to a friend in another room, and what about it made you want to hand it over?
4 "Girl's girl" is a phrase people use like a compliment and sometimes like a test. After reading, what does it mean to you, and do you think you have earned it?

Going deep

1 Is there a friendship in your life this book made you want to call, or one it let you finally put down? You do not have to name names.
2 By the last stretch of the book, did you feel comforted or quietly stung, and what in Feldman's writing put you there? Please stay vague on the specifics so nobody gets spoiled.

On the table

Sleepover grilled cheese, cut in triangles

The food of girlhood friendship and staying up too late talking. Easy to make in batches on one griddle.

A big pot of tomato soup with cream swirled in

Comfort in a mug, and it gives everyone something warm to hold while they say the vulnerable thing.

Slice-and-bake chocolate chip cookies, served warm

Low effort, high nostalgia. The book's tenderness pairs best with something still soft in the middle.

To sip

Honey chamomile tea with lemon No alcohol

Non-alcoholic and gentle. Set out a kettle and a basket of tea bags so people can wander back for refills.

Spiced hot cocoa with a splash of bourbon (optional pour)

Indulgent and nurturing, and the optional pour keeps the night low-pressure for everyone.

A soft, chillable red (Beaujolais or Lambrusco)

Friendly, unfussy wine that does not require anyone to have opinions about wine.

Warm, close-mic'd songs about women and the people they love, played just under conversation volume

Tap a track to play it. Full songs play when you're signed into Spotify.