← Back to kit
Question cards Bookmarks Scorecards Download PDF

Tap Download PDF and we'll email you the printable file.

Book Club Night Kit
Plot Twist

Plot Twist

Harlan Coben
Cozy night

Harlan Coben steps out from behind the thriller curtain to talk about the kid he was, the people who shaped him, and how a suspense novel actually gets built. It is an unusually warm, chatty read from a writer most of us know only through his cliffhangers.

Pull Up a Booth: A Cozy Night with Harlan Coben

Baked ziti, bottomless coffee, and the man behind all those cliffhangers telling on himself for once. Come as you are, finish the book or don't, just bring one story of your own.

Reading level: Easy

Best for: A club that likes the author as much as the book, and would rather trade stories than dissect chapters

Discussion

Warm-up

  1. 1.Before opening this, what did you picture Harlan Coben was like as a person? Did the voice on the page match the voice in your head?
  2. 2.Was your first Coben a book, a Netflix binge, or this one? Tell us how he first showed up in your life.

Digging in

  1. 1.He writes so much about ordinary suburban life before everything goes sideways. Which detail of that ordinary world felt most like the street you grew up on?
  2. 2.Which piece of his growing-up made you want to call someone from your own childhood? Who, and what would you say?
  3. 3.There is real tenderness in how he writes about the people who believed in him early. Who was that person for you, and did they ever know?
  4. 4.Reading about how he builds a character, did you feel let in on a secret or did a little of the magic go out of it for you? Be honest, there is no wrong answer here.

Going deep

  1. 1.He is candid about the parts of a writing life that are not glamorous. Did any of that honesty land close to home with your own work or creative thing you keep meaning to do?
  2. 2.A person who writes about secrets for a living chooses what to reveal about himself. Where did you feel him being most generous with you, and where did you feel him gently keeping the door shut? How did that sit with you?

On the table & to sip

To eat

Jersey diner grilled cheese with tomato soup in mugs
Coben is famously a New Jersey guy and his stories live in diners and kitchens. Griddled sandwiches cut into halves, soup in mugs so people can hold it while they talk.
A big sheet pan of baked ziti
The classic Jersey family-table dish. Make it the day before, reheat, serve in bowls. One pan feeds everybody and nobody has to plate anything carefully.
Black and white cookies plus a bowl of pretzels
East Coast childhood snacks, and the black-and-white cookie is a quiet nod to a writer who lives in the gray in between. Store bought is completely fine.

To sip

Bottomless diner coffee with real cream (no alcohol)
Poured from a carafe you leave on the table, refilled without asking, exactly like the booth where half his scenes could happen.
Hot spiced apple cider (no alcohol)
A non-alcoholic option that smells like the whole house is being kind to you. Cinnamon stick, orange slice, keep it warm on the stove.
Amaretto or bourbon added to the coffee, offered on the side
The grown-up upgrade for the back half of the night, set out in one bottle so people help themselves.

Run of show

7:00
Door, mug, seat
Hand everyone a warm drink before they take their coat off. No agenda yet, just let the room fill up.
7:20
Ziti and soup on the table
Serve family style. Eating together first makes the talking part effortless later.
7:45
Warm-up circle
Run the two warm-up questions. Go around once so every voice is in the room early, even the quiet ones.
8:05
The heart of it
Move into the theme questions. Let the tangents happen, this is a book about tangents.
8:45
Cookies, coffee refills, the deeper two
Dessert on the table shifts the energy. Ask the two deep questions while people are picking at cookies.
9:15
Trivia, scorecards, soft landing
Quick trivia for fun, fill out scorecards, pick next month's book, send people home with a bookmark.

Host tips

  • Pick the two theme questions you love most and treat the rest as spares. A cozy night should never feel like it is working through a list.
  • Say out loud at the start that half-finished is welcome. This book is easy to dip into and you will get better stories from people who feel unjudged.
  • Keep a pot or carafe within arm's reach of the group so nobody has to break the conversation to go refill.

Playlist

Low, warm, slightly nostalgic East Coast radio, the kind playing softly in a diner at 10pm

  1. 01 Thunder Road - Bruce Springsteen
  2. 02 Fire and Rain - James Taylor
  3. 03 Homeward Bound - Simon & Garfunkel
  4. 04 The Boys of Summer - Don Henley
  5. 05 Jersey Girl - Tom Waits
  6. 06 Harvest Moon - Neil Young
  7. 07 Cecilia and the Satellite - Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness
  8. 08 Northern Sky - Nick Drake

Trivia

  1. 1.Which U.S. state is Harlan Coben most associated with, both as home and as the setting of much of his fiction? (New Jersey.)
  2. 2.What is the name of the sports agent turned amateur sleuth who anchors Coben's long-running series? (Myron Bolitar.)
  3. 3.Coben signed a multi-year deal with which streaming service to adapt his novels into series? (Netflix.)
  4. 4.Which Coben novel won the Edgar, Shamus, and Anthony awards, a rare sweep for the genre? (Fade Away.)
  5. 5.What is the nickname of Myron Bolitar's famously well-dressed and dangerous best friend? (Win (Windsor Horne Lockwood III).)
  6. 6.Which Ivy League school did Coben attend, and where he was roommates with a future U.S. politician? (Amherst College (his roommate was Dan Brown's fellow alum and future politician Dan Maffei); Coben studied political science there.)
  7. 7.Coben's thrillers are often described as belonging to which subgenre, built on secrets surfacing in seemingly safe neighborhoods? (Suburban or domestic suspense.)
  8. 8.What is the title of this book of stories and reflections on his life and craft? (Plot Twist.)

Bookmarks

Print, cut, and tuck one at every seat, a small keepsake from the night.

Plot Twist

“Every quiet street is somebody's whole entire world.”

Plot Twist
Harlan Coben
bookclubnight.com
Plot Twist

“Pour another cup. The story keeps until morning.”

Plot Twist
Harlan Coben
bookclubnight.com
Plot Twist

“He kept the secrets, then handed us the good ones.”

Plot Twist
Harlan Coben
bookclubnight.com

Rate the book

Warmth☆☆☆☆☆
Made me want to tell my own story☆☆☆☆☆
Voice on the page☆☆☆☆☆
Comfort-read factor☆☆☆☆☆
Would hand to a friend☆☆☆☆☆
One word for how this book left me feeling: ______________________
The story of his I will still be thinking about next week: ______________________
Someone from my life this made me want to call: ______________________
That's a wrap
Thank you for coming

We hope the company was good and the conversation even better. Until the next chapter.