What are good book club discussion questions for Sometimes I Scare Myself?

Spoiler-free questions to get the conversation going: Where did you do most of your reading for this one, and did you need a lamp on? Describe your actual setup, blanket and snack included; Three stories, three flavors of fear. Which title pulled you in before you read a word: 'Never Kill the Medium,' 'The Nightmare House,' or 'All Curses Are Final'?; 'The Nightmare House' plays on the idea that a home can turn against you. What is one small sound or quirk in your own home that has made your stomach drop, even when you knew it was nothing?; Horror can be strangely comforting. Did any part of reading this feel cozy to you, the way a scary story around a fire does, and what made it feel that way instead of just unsettling?; 'Never Kill the Medium' sits in the world of people who claim to speak with the dead. Have you ever had a reading, a Ouija board night, or a fortune told to you? How did you feel walking away from it?.

What food and drinks should I serve at a Sometimes I Scare Myself book club?

Food: Haunted house chili with cornbread on the side, Medium-rare cheddar and apple grilled cheese, cut into small triangles, and Spiced apple hand pies with a knife slit on top. Drinks: Mulled cider with cinnamon, orange and star anise (non-alcoholic), Hot buttered rum, 'for courage', and Red wine with a splash of the cider, served warm.

Cozy night

Sometimes I Scare MyselfBook club questions, food & host guide

Jeneva Rose

#6 New York Times Fiction Bestseller 1 week on the list

A cozy book club night for Sometimes I Scare Myself by Jeneva Rose. Includes 8 spoiler-free discussion questions, food and drink pairings, a playlist, and a host guide, ready to print and share.

A club that likes a little dread with their blanket and mug, and would rather swap feelings than dissect symbolism

Print / Save PDF Build another Get it on Bookshop.org Get it on Amazon

Buy links are affiliate links; we may earn a small commission, at no cost to you.

Three short horror stories from thriller favorite Jeneva Rose, perfect for a club that wants chills in bite-size servings and a lot to talk about afterward. Because each story stands alone, everyone arrives with something to say, even the person who read it in one sitting the night before.

Why it works for clubs

Short-story format means three separate conversations instead of one, and no one gets lost
Easy to finish in a sitting or two, so attendance and completion rates stay high
Everyone will have a favorite of the three, and the disagreements are friendly ones
Horror in small doses invites personal stories: superstitions, haunted childhood houses, things we half believe

Themes & mood

Spooky but gentle Short and bingeable Curses and hauntings Fireside creepy Low commitment

Browse all themes →

Reading level

Easy

Warm-up questions

1 Where did you do most of your reading for this one, and did you need a lamp on? Describe your actual setup, blanket and snack included.
2 Three stories, three flavors of fear. Which title pulled you in before you read a word: 'Never Kill the Medium,' 'The Nightmare House,' or 'All Curses Are Final'?

Digging in

1 'The Nightmare House' plays on the idea that a home can turn against you. What is one small sound or quirk in your own home that has made your stomach drop, even when you knew it was nothing?
2 Horror can be strangely comforting. Did any part of reading this feel cozy to you, the way a scary story around a fire does, and what made it feel that way instead of just unsettling?
3 'Never Kill the Medium' sits in the world of people who claim to speak with the dead. Have you ever had a reading, a Ouija board night, or a fortune told to you? How did you feel walking away from it?
4 Rose builds dread in very few pages. Was there a moment where you felt your shoulders climb up toward your ears, and did you keep reading or put the book down and go get a snack? No wrong answer here.

Going deep

1 'All Curses Are Final' suggests some things cannot be undone. Without giving anything away, did the collection leave you feeling that people get what is coming to them, or that fate is just indifferent? Which of those is more comforting to you personally?
2 Of the three, which one stayed with you after you closed the book, and what did it stir up in you? Think less about craft and more about what it touched: a worry you carry, a place you lived, a person you miss.

On the table

Haunted house chili with cornbread on the side

A big warm pot you can ladle from all night. It is the dish you want when the story is set in a house you would never sleep in, and it lets guests settle in with a bowl on their lap.

Medium-rare cheddar and apple grilled cheese, cut into small triangles

A gentle nod to 'Never Kill the Medium' and an excuse for the warmest, most indulgent comfort food there is. Easy to make in batches and pass around on a tray.

Spiced apple hand pies with a knife slit on top

Three stories, three bites each. The sealed, slightly ominous little pastries fit the curse-and-consequence mood while tasting entirely like autumn kindness.

To sip

Mulled cider with cinnamon, orange and star anise (non-alcoholic) No alcohol

Keep it warm on the stove so the whole house smells like a safe place. The ideal thing to hold while someone describes the creepiest room they ever slept in.

Hot buttered rum, 'for courage'

Rich, buttery and a little indulgent, exactly what you want between stories. Offer it as an optional pour alongside the cider.

Red wine with a splash of the cider, served warm

A casual, low-effort mulled wine that leans into the fireside-tale feeling without any cocktail shaking.

Hushed and warm with a faint chill underneath, like a record playing in a house that creaks a little. Quiet enough to talk over.

Tap a track to play it. Full songs play when you're signed into Spotify.