What are good book club discussion questions for The Amateur?

Spoiler-free questions to get the conversation going: Grab a cozy seat. Where did you do most of your reading, and did the setting of this book pair well with your reading nook?; What is a small comfort (a snack, a blanket, a playlist) that got you through the tense parts of this one?; The country club world runs on appearances. When in your own life have you felt the pull to keep something polished on the outside, and how did that feel?; The protagonist is a young prodigy carrying enormous pressure. Did any of her moments make you want to reach into the page and offer her tea, and why?; Bohjalian writes ordinary people caught inside extraordinary trouble. Which character did you find yourself feeling most tender toward, even if you did not fully approve of them?.

What food and drinks should I serve at a The Amateur book club?

Food: Clubhouse chicken salad sliders on soft rolls, Warm tomato soup with grilled cheese fingers, and Brown butter apple crumble with vanilla ice cream. Drinks: Spiced apple cider (warm, non-alcoholic), Bourbon and honey hot toddy, and Chamomile-lavender tea with honey.

How do I host a The Amateur book club night?

A propulsive, twisty tale where a tragic accident on a manicured country club green cracks open a world of secrets. Perfect for a slow, snuggly night of gasps and gentle debate.

The Amateur Book Club Questions, Food & Host Guide

Warm-up questions

1 Grab a cozy seat. Where did you do most of your reading, and did the setting of this book pair well with your reading nook?
2 What is a small comfort (a snack, a blanket, a playlist) that got you through the tense parts of this one?

Digging in

1 The country club world runs on appearances. When in your own life have you felt the pull to keep something polished on the outside, and how did that feel?
2 The protagonist is a young prodigy carrying enormous pressure. Did any of her moments make you want to reach into the page and offer her tea, and why?
3 Bohjalian writes ordinary people caught inside extraordinary trouble. Which character did you find yourself feeling most tender toward, even if you did not fully approve of them?
4 Golf, greens, clubhouses: this world can feel both idyllic and suffocating. What mood did the setting leave you sitting with when you closed the book?

Going deep

1 Without giving anything away, was there a moment that genuinely unsettled you, and what do you think it stirred up personally?
2 The story lives in the gray space between accident, blame, and what people will do to protect their own. How did the book shift, even a little, the way you think about second chances?

On the table

Clubhouse chicken salad sliders on soft rolls

A homey nod to the country club lunch counter, easy to plate and pass around a coffee table

Warm tomato soup with grilled cheese fingers

Pure comfort for a story with a dark undercurrent; something soft to hold while you gasp

Brown butter apple crumble with vanilla ice cream

New England orchard warmth honoring Bohjalian's Vermont roots

To sip

Spiced apple cider (warm, non-alcoholic) No alcohol

Cozy, autumnal, and perfect for cradling during the twistier chapters

Bourbon and honey hot toddy

A gentle nod to clubhouse drinks, softened into something snuggly

Chamomile-lavender tea with honey No alcohol

For calming the nerves after a particularly tense chapter

Hushed, lightly haunted acoustic warmth with a thread of unease

Tap a track to play it. Full songs play when you're signed into Spotify.