What are good book club discussion questions for The Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook?

Spoiler-free questions to get the conversation going: If you could have a cat companion like Princess Donut curled up next to you tonight, what would she complain about first in this room?; Where were you, and what were you snacking on, the first time this book made you laugh out loud?; Carl keeps showing up for the people around him even when he's exhausted. Who in your own life is your 'Carl,' the steady one who keeps you going?; The dungeon is terrifying, but the books keep finding small pockets of rest and safety. What does a real safe room look like for you after a hard week?; Donut can be vain, dramatic, and fiercely loyal all at once. Did she remind you of anyone you love (pet or person), and what makes that mix so endearing?.

What food and drinks should I serve at a The Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook book club?

Food: Safe Room Beef Stew in Bread Bowls, Subway Platform Soft Pretzels with Warm Cheese Dip, and Princess Donut's Royal Tuna Melts. Drinks: Loot Box Hot Cocoa Bar, Crawler's Spiked Mulled Cider, and Coast Guard Honey Chai.

Cozy night

The Dungeon Anarchist's CookbookBook club questions, food & host guide

Matt Dinniman

A cozy book club night for The Dungeon Anarchist's Cookbook by Matt Dinniman. Includes 8 spoiler-free discussion questions, food and drink pairings, a playlist, and a host guide, ready to print and share.

A laid-back group of friends who like big laughs, big hearts, and trading favorite moments over a warm mug

Print / Save PDF Build another Get it on Bookshop.org Get it on Amazon

Buy links are affiliate links; we may earn a small commission, at no cost to you.

Carl and Princess Donut head underground into a subway system full of monsters, and it's as funny, chaotic, and surprisingly tender as the first two books. It works well for a cozy night because under all the explosions it's really a story about sticking together when everything is falling apart.

Why it works for clubs

Laugh-out-loud humor gives everyone an easy way into the conversation
The friendship between Carl and Donut brings out warm, personal stories
Its themes of kindness, grief, and found family feel real even in an absurd world
Readers who love the series will be excited to share their favorite moments

Themes & mood

Found family Gallows humor Hope underground Unlikely friendship Comfort in chaos

Reading level

Easy

Warm-up questions

1 If you could have a cat companion like Princess Donut curled up next to you tonight, what would she complain about first in this room?
2 Where were you, and what were you snacking on, the first time this book made you laugh out loud?

Digging in

1 Carl keeps showing up for the people around him even when he's exhausted. Who in your own life is your 'Carl,' the steady one who keeps you going?
2 The dungeon is terrifying, but the books keep finding small pockets of rest and safety. What does a real safe room look like for you after a hard week?
3 Donut can be vain, dramatic, and fiercely loyal all at once. Did she remind you of anyone you love (pet or person), and what makes that mix so endearing?
4 The humor in this book sits right next to some real sadness. Has laughter ever helped you get through something heavy, and did the book bring that to mind?

Going deep

1 Thinking about the whole book, was there a quiet moment of kindness or connection that stayed with you longer than the big action scenes? Why do you think it hit you so hard?
2 By the end, how do you feel about the way Carl is changing? Did it make you worried for him, proud of him, or a little of both, and has it changed how you think about staying yourself under pressure?

On the table

Safe Room Beef Stew in Bread Bowls

A hearty, slow-simmered stew that tastes like finally making it to a safe place after a long crawl. You can make it a day ahead, so the host gets to relax too.

Subway Platform Soft Pretzels with Warm Cheese Dip

A nod to the underground transit setting and to the snacks you grab at a station, served warm and buttery so they feel cozy instead of like fast food.

Princess Donut's Royal Tuna Melts

Golden, gooey tuna melts cut into small triangles, fit for a cat who demands only the finest. They're easy to make and filling, and they always get a laugh.

To sip

Loot Box Hot Cocoa Bar No alcohol

Rich hot chocolate with a 'loot box' of mix-ins (marshmallows, crushed peppermint, caramel, sprinkles) so every guest gets a surprise reward.

Crawler's Spiked Mulled Cider

Warm spiced apple cider with a splash of bourbon or spiced rum, a comforting reward for surviving another floor.

Coast Guard Honey Chai No alcohol

A soothing honey-sweetened chai in honor of Carl's Coast Guard past. It's warm, steady, and dependable, just like him. Serve a caffeine-free rooibos version for later in the evening.

Warm, gently playful tunes about trains, cats, and friendship, like a soft soundtrack for a safe room

04 Everybody Wants to Be a Cat - The Aristocats Cast

Tap a track to play it. Full songs play when you're signed into Spotify.