What are good book club discussion questions for Homemade?

Spoiler-free questions to get the conversation going: What is the one thing you would never make from scratch, and what is the one thing you secretly love making the long way?; Did you cook anything from the book, or just read it in bed and feel soothed? Both are completely valid, tell us which one you were; The book treats everyday cooking as something worth slowing down for. Was there a page where that idea felt genuinely comforting to you, and one where it quietly made you feel behind?; Nara writes a lot about feeding her own family. Whose kitchen did this book return you to, and what did that room smell like?; Which recipe did you find yourself bookmarking not because you plan to make it, but because reading it was nice? What was the appeal?.

What food and drinks should I serve at a Homemade book club?

Food: A warm loaf with cultured butter and flaky salt, A pot of something braised with buttered noodles or rice, and Homemade granola or a crumbly fruit bake for the end. Drinks: Spiced honey milk (non-alcoholic), Big pot of cardamom tea, refilled all night, and Hot buttered rum or a mulled cider with a splash of brandy.

Cozy night

HomemadeBook club questions, food & host guide

Nara Aziza Smith

#7 New York Times Bestseller 1 week on the list

A cozy book club night for Homemade by Nara Aziza Smith. Includes 8 spoiler-free discussion questions, food and drink pairings, a playlist, and a host guide, ready to print and share.

A club that likes to cook for each other and would rather swap stories than build arguments

Print / Save PDF Build another Get it on Bookshop.org Get it on Amazon

Buy links are affiliate links; we may earn a small commission, at no cost to you.

Nara Smith's debut is a from-scratch cookbook and gentle manifesto about making food slowly, with your hands, for the people in your house. It is less a book to argue about and more a book to cook from together, which makes it an unusually warm, hands-on club pick.

Why it works for clubs

Everyone arrives with an opinion about from-scratch cooking, which makes the table talk immediate
Invites real stories about family kitchens, inherited recipes, and what home tasted like growing up
Sits at the crossroads of food, domesticity, and internet culture, so there is plenty to turn over gently
Members can actually make something from it before the meeting, so the book shows up on the table

Themes & mood

From scratch Domestic warmth Slow living Family table Comfort

Browse all themes →

Reading level

Easy

Warm-up questions

1 What is the one thing you would never make from scratch, and what is the one thing you secretly love making the long way?
2 Did you cook anything from the book, or just read it in bed and feel soothed? Both are completely valid, tell us which one you were.

Digging in

1 The book treats everyday cooking as something worth slowing down for. Was there a page where that idea felt genuinely comforting to you, and one where it quietly made you feel behind?
2 Nara writes a lot about feeding her own family. Whose kitchen did this book return you to, and what did that room smell like?
3 Which recipe did you find yourself bookmarking not because you plan to make it, but because reading it was nice? What was the appeal?
4 Making bread or cereal from nothing can feel like love or like a chore depending on the day. Where do you personally land, and has this book nudged you at all?

Going deep

1 Nara came to this book through a very public internet life, and the book itself is quiet and domestic. What did it feel like to spend a few hours in her version of home, and did it change how you read her?
2 By the time you closed the book, had your idea of what counts as 'taking care of people' softened, expanded, or stayed exactly where it was? Tell us honestly, no one is grading.

On the table

A warm loaf with cultured butter and flaky salt

Bread from scratch is the beating heart of this book, and tearing a loaf apart at the table sets an instantly unhurried tone. Store-bought is allowed, nobody will check.

A pot of something braised with buttered noodles or rice

One-pot, made ahead, ladled into mismatched bowls. It matches the book's unfussy, feed-everyone spirit without putting the host in the kitchen all night.

Homemade granola or a crumbly fruit bake for the end

A nod to the book's signature habit of making pantry staples by hand. Serve the crumble warm with cold cream and let people go back for seconds.

To sip

Spiced honey milk (non-alcoholic) No alcohol

Steamed milk, honey, cinnamon, a scrape of nutmeg. Pure from-scratch comfort and a lovely thing to hold while someone tells a long story about their grandmother.

Big pot of cardamom tea, refilled all night No alcohol

A warm, fragrant anchor for the table. Set it out with a jug of milk and let people pour their own, which keeps the whole night low-pressure.

Hot buttered rum or a mulled cider with a splash of brandy

Gently indulgent, smells like the whole house is being taken care of. Keep the unspiked cider on the stove beside it.

Low, golden, kitchen-at-dusk music. Soft piano, brushed drums, and voices that sound like they are singing to one room.

Tap a track to play it. Full songs play when you're signed into Spotify.