← Back to kit
Question cards Bookmarks Scorecards Download PDF
Want this emailed to you? or just download it above. We'll send a reminder before your meeting too.
Book Club Night Kit
Making Peace With What I Can't Control

Making Peace With What I Can't Control

Lysa TerKeurst
Cozy night

Lysa TerKeurst offers a tender, honest look at what happens when life refuses to follow our carefully made plans, and how peace can be found anyway. It is a gentle read that invites readers to unclench their fists a little.

Bring Your Softest Socks and Your Unanswered Questions

We are gathering around soup, crumble, and Lysa TerKeurst's Making Peace With What I Can't Control. Come as you are, finished or not, with nothing to prove.

Reading level: Easy

Best for: A close-knit club that likes soft blankets, honest talk, and second helpings of dessert

Discussion

Warm-up

  1. 1.Where did you do most of your reading for this one, and did you find yourself reaching for tea, a blanket, or a pen to underline with?
  2. 2.Was there a page where you had to stop, set the book down, and just breathe for a minute? What was happening in it?

Digging in

  1. 1.The book keeps circling the idea of unclenching. What is something small you have been gripping this week that you would like to loosen your hold on tonight?
  2. 2.Lysa writes about disappointment that does not get tidied up. Did reading that make you feel comforted, uneasy, or a little of both?
  3. 3.Was there a line or idea in here that felt like it was handed to you personally, almost like someone had been listening in on your last hard year?
  4. 4.The book treats peace as something you make rather than something you find. Which of those two versions of peace has felt truer in your own life?

Going deep

  1. 1.Lysa is honest about the seasons where trust and faith felt thin. If you have been in one of those seasons, what did company or comfort look like for you then, and did this book name any of it well?
  2. 2.By the last pages the book leaves you somewhere different from where it started, without tying every thread. How did you feel setting it down, and is there something you have made a quiet peace with that you are willing to share?

On the table & to sip

To eat

Slow-simmered chicken and rice soup
The book is essentially a bowl of soup handed to someone having a hard year, so serve the literal version in mismatched mugs.
Skillet cornbread with honey butter
Homey, Southern-leaning comfort that nods to the author's North Carolina roots, and it needs no plating or fuss.
Warm apple crumble with cream
Imperfect, spooned straight from the pan, sweet in the middle of something messy: the whole thesis of the night in dessert form.

To sip

Honey chamomile tea with lemon (no alcohol)
A nervous-system-soothing pot to keep refilling while people talk about hard things gently.
Salted maple hot chocolate (no alcohol)
Indulgent and a little salty-sweet, for the readers who came to be comforted, not challenged.
Mulled red wine with orange and clove
Warm, spiced, and slow-sipping, the kind of glass that keeps a conversation soft instead of sharp.

Run of show

7:00
Soup and settling in
Soup on the stove, mugs out, no seating chart. Let people ladle and land wherever they want.
7:20
Blanket and bookmark handout
Pass out printed bookmarks and let everyone pick the line that matches their week. Instant low-pressure icebreaker.
7:35
Warm-up circle
Two warm-up questions only. Go around once so every voice is in the room before anything tender comes up.
7:55
Theme conversation
Work through the theme questions loosely. Silence is allowed here, do not rush to fill it.
8:30
Crumble and deep questions
Serve dessert first, then ask the two deep questions. People open up more with a spoon in hand.
9:00
Trivia, scorecards, and soft landing
Lighten the mood with trivia, fill out scorecards, pick next month's book, send leftovers home.

Host tips

  • Say out loud at the start that passing on any question is completely fine. This book touches real grief and people need the exit door named.
  • Keep the lights low and lamps on instead of overheads, and have more blankets than you think you need.
  • Have a stack of index cards out for anyone who would rather write their answer than say it. Read the anonymous ones aloud if the group is willing.

Playlist

Hushed acoustic and piano-forward songs about holding on loosely, played low enough to talk over.

  1. 01 Holocene - Bon Iver
  2. 02 Let It Be - The Beatles
  3. 03 Peace - Taylor Swift
  4. 04 River - Leon Bridges
  5. 05 Oceans (Where Feet May Fail) - Hillsong UNITED
  6. 06 The Wisdom To Know The Difference - Ólafur Arnalds
  7. 07 Slow Burn - Kacey Musgraves
  8. 08 Be Still - The Fray

Trivia

  1. 1.Who wrote Making Peace With What I Can't Control? (Lysa TerKeurst.)
  2. 2.What ministry organization is Lysa TerKeurst the longtime leader of? (Proverbs 31 Ministries.)
  3. 3.What US state is Lysa TerKeurst based in? (North Carolina.)
  4. 4.Which genre shelf would you find this book on: literary thriller, Christian nonfiction, or historical fiction? (Christian nonfiction (inspirational/devotional).)
  5. 5.Lysa TerKeurst is also the author of a bestseller with the title It's Not Supposed to Be This ______. (Way.)
  6. 6.Which bestseller list has Lysa TerKeurst repeatedly appeared on? (The New York Times bestseller list.)
  7. 7.Name another Lysa TerKeurst title built around the theme of releasing hurt toward others. (Forgiving What You Can't Forget.)
  8. 8.Is this book structured as one continuous narrative or as shorter readings you can take a piece at a time? (Shorter, digestible readings.)

Bookmarks

Print, cut, and tuck one at every seat, a small keepsake from the night.

Making Peace With What I Can't Control

“Unclench. The soup is hot and nobody is grading you.”

Making Peace With What I Can't Control
Lysa TerKeurst
bookclubnight.com
Making Peace With What I Can't Control

“Some peace is not found. It is simmered slowly.”

Making Peace With What I Can't Control
Lysa TerKeurst
bookclubnight.com
Making Peace With What I Can't Control

“Hold your plans like a warm mug, not a fist.”

Making Peace With What I Can't Control
Lysa TerKeurst
bookclubnight.com

Rate the book

Comfort factor☆☆☆☆☆
Honesty☆☆☆☆☆
Gentleness☆☆☆☆☆
Lines worth underlining☆☆☆☆☆
Would reread on a hard day☆☆☆☆☆
One word for how this book left me: ______________________
The page I want to hand to a friend: ______________________
Something I am setting down tonight: ______________________
That's a wrap
Thank you for coming

We hope the company was good and the conversation even better. Until the next chapter.